ComputerWeekly

I am the passenger: In Brussels at Google’s data sovereignty event


As Mr I Pop so astutely pointed out, it’s from the viewpoint of the passenger that you see “the city’s ripped backsides”. And this is very much the case as our Eurostar creeps into Brussels.

Many main railway stations have less than salubrious surroundings, and that’s the case with Brussels Midi. As my driver nudges the Merc slowly away from the chaotic station frontage, the surroundings are down at heel, jumbled architecturally and ethnically, as Express Afro-Indian sits alongside Centro Asturiano and Alice Carroll – Atelier Galerie.

A little further on and we strike out onto a wide boulevard. Sat in a traffic jam, I realise we’re in the embassy district. That’s a Bahraini flag overhanging the grand frontage beside me. Others soon slide past – Brazil, Saudi, Romania, Tanzania, etc.

Diplomatic baggage

I’m in Brussels for Google’s AI Sovereignty Symposium, and embassies are a good thing to consider here. They are a microcosm of what sovereignty is all about in the real world. Law enforcement in the country in which they are sited is not allowed in without express permission, and, of course, diplomatic baggage allows for movement in and out of almost any object without interference. That’s an incredibly clear set of boundaries.

Data sovereignty is a different kettle of fish. Even located in their own country, organisations do not have the level of data security from foreign law enforcement an embassy has in a foreign one. And, of course, here we’re really talking about security from US agencies, which have laws that allow them to compel US companies to provide data and to gag the company from revealing that. If we also take into account Five Eyes collaboration, then that scenario could potentially work across the countries involved there too.

The result is a lot of confused and confusing talk around data sovereignty. There are undoubtedly people that believe, and people who would lead them to believe, that simply placing data in a local cloud region somehow makes it sovereign. But it is not. Nobody who has really examined the issue of data sovereignty is under any illusion.

But back to Brussels.

Twenty-five minutes or so after leaving the station, we’re on a peripheral boulevard. Wide. Leafy. Wooded out beyond the edges of the city, off to our right.

And we arrive. A bronzed-glass brutalist structure (pictured), and apparently somewhere inside is a hotel (Mix Brussels), but from the outside it looks like a municipal library or museum.

I float around the first evening reception at the Google event attempting to fend off hunger with multiple breadsticks and olives, and I chat with some people.

In the room

One chap, from a DC-based think tank, says “No serious person in this room is going to tell you that a European organisation can be in partnership with an American company and be truly sovereign with the powers of the CLOUD Act and FISA 702.”

Then there’s a lady from a neocloud company. She says her interest in data sovereignty is because her company offers sovereign datacentres. “But what about the hardware or the software if it comes from an American company?” I ask. She’s frank. “The hardware can never be sovereign,” she says.

I’m prepared to accept that such comments are typical of anyone who’s really looked into the question. So, it seems, is Google.

Google’s pitch

Next day, as the morning keynotes progress, it soon feels like Google is cheerleading European strength as an independent bloc. It’s not altogether a foolish move. Google offers air-gapped solutions, and those in which local partners can run cloud solutions based on Google technology where updates and keys can be handled outside of Google’s control. These approximate most closely to something we’d recognise as providing sovereignty. They also offer the (completely illusory) guarantees of data residency within specific regions, of course, which routinely route data / metadata to foreign parts as part of the cloud provider’s global operations.

But, it seems to me, that here Google has realised it can’t ignore a growing realisation in Europe that IT infrastructure should be far less dependent on US companies, and is building a strategy to sell itself as a partner to those companies and states that realise this.



Source link