ComputerWeekly

States meet to discuss binding rules for autonomous weapons


Human rights campaigners are urging the international community to immediately begin negotiating legally binding rules for the use of autonomous weapons systems, as states assemble in Geneva for a global conference on the issue.

Between 17 and 20 November 2026, states will meet at the United Nations (UN)-convened Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) for its seventh conference, where they will discuss the potential regulation of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS) that can select and kill targets without human oversight or intervention.

Such systems are already being used on battlefields, particularly in the Russia-Ukraine conflict, where weapons powered by artificial intelligence (AI) have killed soldiers and civilians.

Speaking with New Scientist, CEO of Ukrainian drone manufacturer Aero Center Alexander Kokhanovskyy told the publication that a test of its fully autonomous drone capabilities in 2024 ended with the deaths of two Russian soldiers: “We just launch it and we know everything will be dead – everything that will be found there in this particular area will be dead.”

AI-powered targeting systems are also increasingly being used in other contexts, with devastating consequences.

It is now well-documented, for example, that the Israeli Defense Force (IDF) is using data analytics and AI-powered tools in Gaza to generate huge “kill lists” and make strike recommendations on an industrial scale.

One former Israeli intelligence officer told Israeli media outlet +972 that the IDF’s web of AI-powered targeting systems – including Lavender, Gospel and Where’s Daddy? – essentially work to facilitate a “mass assassination factory”.

In February 2026, the US military also relied on AI-powered targeting to strike 1,000 targets in the first 24 hours of its attacks on Iran. One of the targets hit was a school in Minab, which killed more than 120 children.

AI-enabled drone swarms have also been documented in Sudan, where they have been deployed as autonomous loitering munitions.

Potential negotiating positions

Ahead of the CCW conference, in September 2026, the 128 states parties to the CCW adopted by consensus the final report of the Group of Governmental Experts (GGE) on autonomous weapons, which sets out the “elements of a [legal] instrument, without prejudging its nature, and other possible measures to address LAWS”.

Some of the report’s proposed measures include full lifecycle testing of weapons systems, accountability arrangements that ensure human command and control, and placing operational guardrails on states deploying the technology.

The outcome of the CCW conference will decide whether anyone who builds or fields AI-enabled targeting systems faces a legally binding international text, or only voluntary guidance

The report also clarified that legal obligations apply to states and individuals, not machines, meaning legal liability for military actions cannot be transferred to autonomous systems.

It further noted that international humanitarian law (IHL) “governs the use of all weapons, means and methods of warfare, those of the past, those of the present, and those of the future, including those incorporating emerging technologies in the area of LAWS”.

However, while the vast majority of countries now support regulating autonomous weapons, a small number of countries – including the US, UK, Russia, India and Israel – remain steadfast in their opposition to new binding rules, arguing that existing ​humanitarian law is sufficient.

The US specifically favours voluntary guidelines, submitting a working paper to the CCW on 4 November 2026 that proposed five more years of consensus-based work towards a non-binding instrument. The paper further argued that the appropriate use of LAWS can “reduce the risks to civilians” compared with weapons that lack autonomous capabilities.

Given the overwhelming global consensus that autonomous weapons systems should be subject to new rules regulating their use, campaigners are urging states to “meet the moment” and agree to launch treaty negotiations immediately.

The outcome of the CCW conference will decide whether anyone who builds or fields AI-enabled targeting systems faces a legally binding international text, or only voluntary guidance. However, CCW decisions require consensus, giving any one government veto power over the discussions.

Inadequacy of IHL

According to León Castellanos-Jankiewicz, a senior researcher in International Law at the University of Amsterdam Faculty of Law and a non-resident fellow at the UN Institute for Disarmament Research, the increasing use of autonomous weapons presents difficulties for the application of international humanitarian law.

“Many AI-enabled weapons are black boxes. Given their ability to adapt in real time, machine learning systems are responsive to countless environmental stimuli. To achieve their goals, they can identify and exploit opportunities that their designers did not foresee, exhibiting what scientists describe as ‘emergent’ behavior. Put simply, their choices cannot be fully predicted or explained ahead of time as required by law,” he wrote in November 2026.

“Kill decisions are also deeply networked, arising from sensor and platform interaction rather than from a single, isolated judgment. In contrast, international humanitarian law assumes unity of purpose by treating each attack as flowing from a discrete decision; yet new technologies like drone swarms are decentralized by definition.”

Commenting on the latest CCW report drafted ahead of the conference in Geneva, Castellanos-Jankiewicz said although it is a good start, it fails to close the enforcement gap for weapons systems operating in unobserved environments.

“The report’s language covers human control before and during deployment. But once a drone is jammed, only inputs made prior to launch remain relevant for liability,” he wrote, adding that generally limited target verification and an inability to tie human intent to specific attacks makes it hard to apply accountability under international law as it is currently built.

“Worryingly, the text assigns no responsibility to the tech companies building these systems, who fiercely protect their commercial secrets from public scrutiny.

“This new algorithmic reality urgently needs new rules that reach beyond individual human intent: enforceable obligations for states that field unpredictable killing machines, and liability for the companies that build them.”

Calls for action

Campaign groups like the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Stop Killer Robots, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have all urged states party to the CCW to adopt a mandate for negotiations on a new legally binding protocol, which must be negotiated within one year – by the end of 2027.

“These new military tools pose potential threats to civilian protection and to long-standing, core principles of international humanitarian and human rights law. These weapons systems, or components, risk disproportionately harming populations that are already subject to greater violence and discrimination,” said Stop Killer Robots.  

The vast majority of states worldwide are in favour of a new legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons systems. This is urgently needed to ensure humans remain in control and accountable on the battlefield
Nicole van Rooijen, Stop Killer Robots

“New international legal rules are the only logical and morally acceptable next step. Anything less would be unacceptably weak in the face of the clear and urgent dangers from autonomous weapons systems.”

It added that any legally binding instrument should contain both prohibitions and positive obligations. This should include prohibitions on weapons systems that target people, as well as those that do not allow for meaningful human control, and obligations to ensure all other systems are effectively controlled and understood.

“We are at a critical juncture. The vast majority of states worldwide are in favour of a new legally binding instrument on autonomous weapons systems,” said Nicole van Rooijen, executive director of Stop Killer Robots.

“This is urgently needed to ensure humans remain in control and accountable on the battlefield. Civilians must be better protected. States must adopt a negotiation mandate and a commitment to getting it done within one year.”

Verity Coyle, deputy director for arms in the crisis, conflict and arms division at Human Rights Watch, added that history will not judge states by how long they discussed LAWS, but by whether they acted before meaningful human control was lost.

“With reports of increasingly autonomous weapons already emerging from contemporary conflicts, governments face a clear choice: launch treaty negotiations now or allow the rules of war to be rewritten by technological developments and battlefield practice. Human lives are too important to leave to algorithms.”

The ICRC also said that a one-year negotiating mandate for a new protocol on autonomous weapons “would demonstrate that the Convention remains credible and capable of addressing contemporary challenges, while delivering on its fundamental promise: to alleviate human suffering in war”.



Source link