A British court has confirmed that the Home Office has issued a secret order to provide police and intelligence services with the capability to access encrypted data stored by users of Apple devices.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal found that government claims that confirming the existence of the order, known as a Technical Capability Notice (TCN), would damage national security were unfounded.
The tribunal rejected arguments from the Home Office that revealing the existence of the secret order, which has been widely reported in the press, and publicly referred to by senior members of the Trump administration, would damage national security. It found that the Home Office had failed to consistently follow its policy of neither confirming nor denying (NCND) the existence of the order, undermining government arguments that it should remain secret.
The case represents the second time this year that the government has been forced to back down on assertions of NCND to protect claimed government secrets. It follows the Agent X case, in which MI5 was found to have lied to two courts and misled an oversight body to protect a neo-Nazi informant who had abused his partner.
Existence of TCN already confirmed
Three judges found today (19 November) that despite the UK government’s claimed secrecy over the order issued to Apple, government officials had confirmed the existence of the TCN to newspaper journalists and to US government officials.
A leak to the Washington Post first revealed that the Home Office issued a technical capability notice to Apple in January 2025 requiring it to provide access to end-to-end encrypted messages and data stored by Apple’s customers worldwide in iCloud.
The existence of the order was confirmed by the former US director of national intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard, in a post on X in August 2025, which exceeded three million views, after the US administration raised concerns that the order would allow the UK to access data on American citizens.
The court also found that UK government officials gave briefings to the Times and the Financial Times confirming the existence of the secret order.
Apple, Privacy International and Liberty are challenging the home secretary’s legal powers to issue technical capability notices to technology companies in the Investigatory Powers Tribunal.
The government can use TCNs to require tech companies to modify their services to provide police and intelligence services access to their users’ data. Rather than comply, Apple withdrew its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) service from UK users, stating: “We have never built a backdoor or master key to any of our products and services and never will.”
The tribunal found that the government had not consistently applied its policy of neither confirming nor denying the existence of the order. Two different reputable newspapers had reported that government officials departed from NCND and positively confirmed the existence of the technical capability notice, it said.
Claims by the Home Office that internal leak investigations failed to find a government source that passed the information on to the press had “little or no evidential value”.
The home secretary had the opportunity to file detailed evidence about internal investigations to a closed hearing of the tribunal but had chosen not to do so, and ministers and government officials chose not to provide statements to the court.
Briefings to media and US officials
The judges inferred that the briefings to newspapers did take place and were authorised by government ministers, senior officials or special advisers.
“It is extremely unlikely that multiple government sources would have briefed the media in the absence of authorisation for such a briefing,” the court found.
The court also found that the UK government had given Apple permission to brief US government officials about the order, without any apparent assurance of confidentiality in what “amounted to a further clear departure from NCND”.
The court noted that it was “abundantly clear” by April 2025 that most senior US officials and politicians were not prepared to keep the order secret, as they regarded it as an “egregious breach” of US citizen’s First Amendment rights.
The cumulative effect was that anyone with even a passing interest in the topic would already know that the Home Office had served a technical capability notice on Apple, the judges found. Anyone could find out the answer to whether a TCN had been issued against Apple by simply typing the question into Google’s chatbot.
The judges agreed with Apple and the NGOs that the home secretary had not established that it would be damaging to national security to confirm the existence of the technical capability notice. The decision will mean that the court will be able to hear arguments over the lawfulness of the home secretary’s powers to issue TCN’s in public hearings.
Judges will decide whether details about the technical capability notice can be disclosed without damaging national security or the public interest in future hearings.
Apple is challenging the lawfulness of the home secretary’s powers to issue TCNs under five grounds (see box). Most of the arguments can be heard in open court without damaging national security, the IPT found today.
Caroline Wilson Palow, legal director at Privacy International, said that the decision was a major victory for transparency and effective oversight, adding: “The Investigatory Powers Tribunal has rightly rejected the UK government’s attempts to shield from scrutiny an issue of immense public interest – whether Apple has been ordered to undermine the security of our devices – based on an unsupported claim of a risk to national security. The government should not be allowed to use its policy of ‘neither confirm nor deny’ as an impenetrable shield.”
Akiko Hart, director of Liberty, said that end-to-end encryption was vital to protect personal information and to securely communicate.
“Encryption protects the things that matter most to us – including our family photos, personal messages, bank details and health records. At a time of growing cyber threats, governments should be rising to the challenge to strengthen digital security protections rather than opening the door to hackers and hostile actors,” she added.
A Home Office spokesperson confirmed the existence of the TCN, saying that the right to privacy should not come at the expense of the safety of the British public: “Apple has been helping the police and intelligence agencies pursue criminals and bring them to justice for several years, in accordance with the law. This Technical Capability Notice simply requires that they maintain the ability to do so.
“Decisions affecting the safety of the British public must be made by democratically elected governments and independent judges, not in the boardrooms of technology companies,” the spokesperson added.

