UK police are continuing to conduct tens of thousands of retrospective facial recognition (RFR) searches on potentially millions of unlawfully retained custody images, the police watchdog has found.
In November 2026, the HM Chief Inspector of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS) published a 58-page report examining how police forces and the National Crime Agency (NCA) are using RFR, after being commissioned by UK home secretary Shabana Mahmood to investigate the matter a year earlier.
Unlike live facial recognition (LFR), which captures and compares people’s faces to a pre-determined watchlist in real time, RFR is applied to already-captured images retroactively, enabling police to compare “probe” images against existing custody images taken when suspects are arrested.
The Home Office originally added an a RFR function to the Police National Database (PND) in 2013, allowing trained and licensed police users to search custody images to identify unknown persons of interest.
As it stands, the PND – which collates data from all 43 police forces in England and Wales, as well as Police Scotland, the Police Service of Northern Ireland, the National Crime Agency and other law enforcement bodies – contains billions of records drawn from several hundred databases, including more than 20 million facial images.
According to the watchdog, its inspection revealed that custody images are still being retained in breach of police information management rules, which set out how forces should review, retain and dispose of custody images.
It noted that while custody image deletion was largely outside the scope of its inspection – which instead focused more on governance arrangements and operational practices – it nonetheless found that “some of the images used in RFR searches should have been deleted and yet were still available for RFR searches”.
It added that this creates a situation that “risks undermining public confidence” in how police are using the technology.
As it stands, UK law enforcement bodies are making more than 300,000 RFR search requests per year.
On top of issues around unlawful custody image retention, the watchdog also found that police use of RFR technology lacked consistent oversight and safeguards, describing a legal and regulatory landscape that is fragmented and underdeveloped.
The “limited oversight”, it added, is compounded by inconsistent approaches to public consultation, transparency and record-keeping across forces, as well as “considerable variation” in how individual forces are using the tech itself.
It also found that police forces often did not have enough management information to understand how effectively they used RFR, or to evaluate the technology’s contribution to crime investigations. This means forces generally “couldn’t clearly show performance improvements from using RFR”.
A long-standing issue
Although it is not mentioned in the report, a High Court ruling in 2012 found the retention of custody images in the PND to be unlawful, on the basis that information about unconvicted people was being treated in the same way as information about people who were ultimately convicted. It also ruled that the six-year retention period was disproportionate.
Despite the 2012 ruling, successive biometric commissioners have warned that millions of custody images are still being unlawfully retained.
Writing to other chief constables to outline some of the issues around custody image retention in February 2022, the National Police Chiefs Council (NPCC) lead for records management, Lee Freeman, said the potentially unlawful retention of millions of custody images “poses a significant risk in terms of potential litigation, police legitimacy and wider support and challenge in our use of these images for technologies such as facial recognition”.
However, HMICFRS said in its report that it was “reassured” by a project launched in October 2023 by the Home Office and NPCC – known as Programme Tabula – to manage the custody image retention issue.
Responding to Computer Weekly’s questions about the custody image issue in November 2023, the NPCC said at the time that “policing needs to ensure transparency and legitimacy in the way we control the use of this important biometric information.”
While a spokesperson confirmed that a national programme had been launched a month earlier “to ensure consistency and co-ordination across UK policing in how it retains, processes and then uses custody images, particularly in the use of facial recognition”, it did not disclose the name of the programme.
“Through the programme, we will agree and implement a robust management regime for custody images to ensure compliance to agreed policies and legislation,” it said. “It is vital to public confidence that this programme is adopted nationally to make sure we are holding data lawfully and ethically, both now and in the future.”
The spokesperson added that while the programme was yet to be publicised, it will seek to establish a management regime for custody images, alongside a review of all currently held data by police forces in the UK, which will be implemented over a two-year period.
“We welcome this work,” said HMICFRS. “It is important that the police service aligns its approach to retaining custody images with other biometric data so that it is consistent and lawful. We look forward to learning how Programme Tabula will support forces in managing custody images more consistently and improving their compliance with legal and data retention requirements.”
Limited oversight
In terms of the wider oversight issues, HMICFRS found that legislation has not kept up with the technology or its use, leading to governance gaps and inconsistent oversight practices.
“Some forces had clear guidance setting out how searches should be carried out, how results should be recorded and what corroborative enquiries were required,” it wrote. “Others lacked formal procedures, which increased the risk of inconsistent decision-making and misunderstanding of the technology’s limitations.
“We found that investigators and supervisors didn’t routinely document the consideration or use of RFR in investigation plans, enquiry logs or supervisory reviews. As a result, forces often lacked clear audit trails showing how RFR results informed decision-making and whether appropriate corroboration had taken place.
“This limits forces’ ability to assess their use of RFR, identify missed opportunities, and provide effective scrutiny and governance.”
On how this translates into practical use, HMICFRS said that police investigators did not always know that RFR results were intelligence rather than evidence, and therefore required further enquiries before officers took enforcement action.
“This creates a risk that people could be incorrectly identified or arrested, which could undermine public confidence in the technology,” it said.
“We found that some investigators didn’t always carry out enough corroborative enquiries before acting on potential matches. In a small number of cases, officers relied too heavily on RFR results, which led to inappropriate investigative action.”
His Majesty’s Inspector of Constabulary Kathryn Stone said continued public support relied on showing the technology was being used properly.
“Police forces must be able to show that appropriate safeguards are in place, risks relating to bias and data retention are effectively managed, and decisions are still subject to human judgment,” she said. “A clearer statutory framework, stronger national standards and improved governance and oversight arrangements are essential to maintaining public confidence.”
Upcoming legislation
In December 2025, the Home Office launched a 10-week consultation on police use of biometrics, including LFR, allowing interested parties and members of the public to share their views on how the controversial technology should be regulated. This also covered other forms of biometric surveillance, including RFR.
This followed on from then-home secretary Yvette Cooper telling a Lords committee in July 2025 that the government intended to create “a proper, clear governance framework” to regulate the use of facial recognition technology by police.
When launching the consultation, the Home Office said that although a “patchwork” legal framework for police use of facial recognition technology exists – including for increasing use of retrospective and “operator-initiated” versions – it does not give police forces the confidence to “use it at significantly greater scale … nor does it consistently give the public the confidence that it will be used responsibly”.
While the government reiterated its intention to bring forward a new legislative framework for police use of biometrics in its formal consultation response, it has so far refrained from committing to specific safeguards, outside of establishing a new independent oversight body (which will consolidate and expand the functions of existing oversight roles) and committing to making public participation in oversight of a statutory requirement.
The government said the framework “will ensure policing can innovate in a repeatable and consistent manner, supporting adoption of emerging biometric and overt surveillance technologies that improve policing effectiveness and public protection, while maintaining appropriate safeguards and oversight”.

